Solver Statistics

From Sokoban Wiki

(Difference between revisions)
Jump to: navigation, search
(→Disclaimer: removed Kenyam since the official number of levels is only 45)
m (Moved the GroupEffort test suite last. Rationale: It's not a test suite of general interest. It's just meant as a rebuttal of a GroupEffort claim.)
Line 1: Line 1:
Sokoban solvers are programs that solve sokoban levels. There are many programs available that can solve Sokoban levels (see [[Links#Sokoban Solvers |Sokoban solvers]]).
Sokoban solvers are programs that solve sokoban levels. There are many programs available that can solve Sokoban levels (see [[Links#Sokoban Solvers |Sokoban solvers]]).
-
There are different solver types:
+
There are different types of solvers:
-
# Solvers which just try to find any solution
+
# Solvers trying to find any solution
-
# Solvers which try to find push optimal solutions
+
# Solvers trying to find push optimal solutions
-
# Solvers which try to find push optimal solutions with best moves
+
# Solvers trying to find push optimal solutions with best moves
-
# Solvers which try to find move optimal solutions
+
# Solvers trying to find move optimal solutions
-
# Solvers which try to find move optimal solutions with best pushes
+
# Solvers trying to find move optimal solutions with best pushes
-
Usually a solver is designed to just find any solution. If the solution is to be optimized an optimizer program can be used ([[Links#Sokoban Solvers |Optimizers]]).
+
Usually, a solver is designed to just find any solution. If the solution is to be optimized an optimizer program can be used ([[Links#Sokoban Solvers |Optimizers]]).
-
To get an impression of what levels are solvable by which solver here are some statistics.<br />  
+
To get an impression of what levels are solvable by which solver, here are some statistics.<br />  
For copyrights, credits and redistribution of these statistics, please read the disclaimer.
For copyrights, credits and redistribution of these statistics, please read the disclaimer.
 +
 +
== XSokoban Test Suite ==
== XSokoban Test Suite ==
Line 77: Line 79:
== Large Test Suite ==
== Large Test Suite ==
-
The large test suite comprises level packs selected for being a challenge for the solvers, but not too difficult. The statistics shows the results for the leading Sokoban solver programs.
+
The large test suite comprises level packs selected for being a challenge for the solvers, but not too difficult. The statistics shows the results for the leading Sokoban solver programs.  
-
The contained levels of this Test Suite will not be changed in the future. Hence it can be considered a new "Large Standard Test Suite" for solvers.
+
This test suite is not subject to change, as it is meant to be a "Large Standard Test Suite" for Sokoban solver programs.  
{| class="soko-table"
{| class="soko-table"
Line 371: Line 373:
|}
|}
-
Download all levels of this Test Suite from [https://sourceforge.net/projects/jsokoapplet/files/LargeTestSuiteSets/Large%20Test%20Suite%20Sets.zip/download here] or from [http://sokobano.de/de/levels.php www.sokobano.de].
+
Download all the test suite levels [https://sourceforge.net/projects/jsokoapplet/files/LargeTestSuiteSets/Large%20Test%20Suite%20Sets.zip/download here] or from [http://sokobano.de/de/levels.php www.sokobano.de].
-
 
+
-
== GroupEffort Test Suite ==
+
-
 
+
-
The reason for benchmarking the GroupEffort test suite is to show the limited veracity of the statement made in section "6 Conclusion" of the thesis, where the author writes that the GroupEffort solver "outperforms existing solvers".
+
-
 
+
-
The benchmarks show that this was only true for the cherry-picked small test set at the time the thesis was published, never for the presumably more representative large test set.
+
-
 
+
-
{| class="soko-table"
+
-
|-
+
-
! colspan="7" | Sokoban Solver Statistics - GroupEffort Test Suite - Solved Levels
+
-
 
+
-
<!-- -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -->
+
-
<!-- The header                                                                                  -->
+
-
<!-- -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -->
+
-
|- bgcolor="#f1efe5" align="center"                <!-- standard format of all rows -->
+
-
| width = "115" align="left" | Collection
+
-
| width =  "80" |                                                        Levels
+
-
| width =  "80" | [https://baldur.iti.kit.edu/theses/SokobanPortfolio.pdf GroupEffort]
+
-
| width =  "80" | [http://codeanalysis.fr/sokoban/                        Sokolution]
+
-
| width =  "80" | [http://www.ic-net.or.jp/home/takaken/e/soko/index.html Takaken]
+
-
| width =  "80" | [https://sourceforge.net/projects/jsokoapplet/          JSoko]
+
-
| width =  "80" | [https://sourceforge.net/projects/sokobanyasc/          YASS]
+
-
 
+
-
<!-- -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -->
+
-
<!-- Small Set                                                                                    -->
+
-
<!-- -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -->
+
-
|- align="right"
+
-
| align="left" bgcolor="#f1efe5" | [[SolverStatistics-GroupEffort-Small-Set | Small Set]]
+
-
| 200
+
-
| 196 (a)(c)
+
-
| [[SolverStatistics-Sokolution-GroupEffort-Small-Set | '''200''' (a) ]]
+
-
| [[SolverStatistics-Takaken-GroupEffort-Small-Set    |    192 (b)    ]]
+
-
| [[SolverStatistics-JSoko-GroupEffort-Small-Set      |    180 (b)    ]]
+
-
| [[SolverStatistics-YASS-GroupEffort-Small-Set      |    191 (b)    ]]
+
-
 
+
-
<!-- -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -->
+
-
<!-- Large Set                                                                                    -->
+
-
<!-- -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -->
+
-
|- align="right"
+
-
| align="left" bgcolor="#f1efe5"| [[SolverStatistics-GroupEffort-Large-Set | Large Set]]
+
-
| 2851
+
-
| 1566 (a)(c)
+
-
| [[SolverStatistics-Sokolution-GroupEffort-Large-Set | '''2471''' (a) ]]
+
-
| [[SolverStatistics-Takaken-GroupEffort-Large-Set    |    2462 (b)    ]]
+
-
| [[SolverStatistics-JSoko-GroupEffort-Large-Set      |    2165 (b)    ]]
+
-
| [[SolverStatistics-YASS-GroupEffort-Large-Set      |    2260 (b)    ]]
+
-
 
+
-
<!-- -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -->
+
-
<!-- Total                                                                                        -->
+
-
<!-- -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -->
+
-
|- align="right" bgcolor="#f1efe5" align="right"
+
-
| align="left"| Total
+
-
|    3051      <!-- Total levels -->
+
-
|    1762      <!-- Group Effort -->
+
-
| '''2671'''  <!-- Sokolution  -->
+
-
|    2654      <!-- Takaken      -->
+
-
|    2345      <!-- JSoko        -->
+
-
|    2471      <!-- YASS        -->
+
-
 
+
-
|}
+
-
 
+
-
(a): Time limit: 5 minutes &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;  (b): Time limit: 10 minutes &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;  (c): Best GroupEffort solver configuration
+
== Solver Statistics ==
== Solver Statistics ==
Line 754: Line 694:
|}
|}
 +
 +
== GroupEffort Test Suite ==
 +
 +
The reason for benchmarking the GroupEffort test suite is to show the limited veracity of the statement made in section "6 Conclusion" of the thesis, where the author writes that the GroupEffort solver "outperforms existing solvers".
 +
 +
The benchmarks show that this was only true for the cherry-picked small test set at the time the thesis was published, never for the presumably more representative large test set.
 +
 +
{| class="soko-table"
 +
|-
 +
! colspan="7" | Sokoban Solver Statistics - GroupEffort Test Suite - Solved Levels
 +
 +
<!-- -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -->
 +
<!-- The header                                                                                  -->
 +
<!-- -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -->
 +
|- bgcolor="#f1efe5" align="center"                <!-- standard format of all rows -->
 +
| width = "115" align="left" | Collection
 +
| width =  "80" |                                                        Levels
 +
| width =  "80" | [https://baldur.iti.kit.edu/theses/SokobanPortfolio.pdf GroupEffort]
 +
| width =  "80" | [http://codeanalysis.fr/sokoban/                        Sokolution]
 +
| width =  "80" | [http://www.ic-net.or.jp/home/takaken/e/soko/index.html Takaken]
 +
| width =  "80" | [https://sourceforge.net/projects/jsokoapplet/          JSoko]
 +
| width =  "80" | [https://sourceforge.net/projects/sokobanyasc/          YASS]
 +
 +
<!-- -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -->
 +
<!-- Small Set                                                                                    -->
 +
<!-- -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -->
 +
|- align="right"
 +
| align="left" bgcolor="#f1efe5" | [[SolverStatistics-GroupEffort-Small-Set | Small Set]]
 +
| 200
 +
| 196 (a)(c)
 +
| [[SolverStatistics-Sokolution-GroupEffort-Small-Set | '''200''' (a) ]]
 +
| [[SolverStatistics-Takaken-GroupEffort-Small-Set    |    192 (b)    ]]
 +
| [[SolverStatistics-JSoko-GroupEffort-Small-Set      |    180 (b)    ]]
 +
| [[SolverStatistics-YASS-GroupEffort-Small-Set      |    191 (b)    ]]
 +
 +
<!-- -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -->
 +
<!-- Large Set                                                                                    -->
 +
<!-- -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -->
 +
|- align="right"
 +
| align="left" bgcolor="#f1efe5"| [[SolverStatistics-GroupEffort-Large-Set | Large Set]]
 +
| 2851
 +
| 1566 (a)(c)
 +
| [[SolverStatistics-Sokolution-GroupEffort-Large-Set | '''2471''' (a) ]]
 +
| [[SolverStatistics-Takaken-GroupEffort-Large-Set    |    2462 (b)    ]]
 +
| [[SolverStatistics-JSoko-GroupEffort-Large-Set      |    2165 (b)    ]]
 +
| [[SolverStatistics-YASS-GroupEffort-Large-Set      |    2260 (b)    ]]
 +
 +
<!-- -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -->
 +
<!-- Total                                                                                        -->
 +
<!-- -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -->
 +
|- align="right" bgcolor="#f1efe5" align="right"
 +
| align="left"| Total
 +
|    3051      <!-- Total levels -->
 +
|    1762      <!-- Group Effort -->
 +
| '''2671'''  <!-- Sokolution  -->
 +
|    2654      <!-- Takaken      -->
 +
|    2345      <!-- JSoko        -->
 +
|    2471      <!-- YASS        -->
 +
 +
|}
 +
 +
(a): Time limit: 5 minutes &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;  (b): Time limit: 10 minutes &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;  (c): Best GroupEffort solver configuration
== Disclaimer ==
== Disclaimer ==

Revision as of 07:02, 24 September 2019

Sokoban solvers are programs that solve sokoban levels. There are many programs available that can solve Sokoban levels (see Sokoban solvers).

There are different types of solvers:

  1. Solvers trying to find any solution
  2. Solvers trying to find push optimal solutions
  3. Solvers trying to find push optimal solutions with best moves
  4. Solvers trying to find move optimal solutions
  5. Solvers trying to find move optimal solutions with best pushes

Usually, a solver is designed to just find any solution. If the solution is to be optimized an optimizer program can be used (Optimizers).

To get an impression of what levels are solvable by which solver, here are some statistics.
For copyrights, credits and redistribution of these statistics, please read the disclaimer.


Contents

XSokoban Test Suite

The XSokoban level set is the de facto standard test suite in the academic literature on Sokoban solver programming.

Sokoban Solver Statistics - XSokoban Test Suite - Solved Levels
Collection Author Levels Junghanns BoxSearch Takaken YASS JSoko Sokolution
XSokoban Thinking Rabbit, ... 90 54 42 86 84 67 80
Sokoban Solver Statistics - XSokoban Test Suite - Push-optimal Solutions
Collection Author Levels Junghanns Pereira et al. JSoko Sokolution
XSokoban Thinking Rabbit, ... 90 6 28 31 38

Large Test Suite

The large test suite comprises level packs selected for being a challenge for the solvers, but not too difficult. The statistics shows the results for the leading Sokoban solver programs.

This test suite is not subject to change, as it is meant to be a "Large Standard Test Suite" for Sokoban solver programs.

Sokoban Solver Statistics - Large Test Suite - Solved Levels
Collection Author Levels BoxSearch Takaken YASS JSoko Sokolution
Aymeric Aymeric du Peloux 282 282 282 282 282 282
Grigr2001 Evgeny Grigoriev 100 93 94 93 92 96
Grigr2002 Evgeny Grigoriev 40 37 37 38 36 40
GrigrSpecial Evgeny Grigoriev 40 39 40 40 39 40
Holland David Holland 81 56 65 59 55 66
Microban David W. Skinner 155 155 155 155 155 155
Microban II David W. Skinner 135 134 134 135 135 132
Sasquatch David W. Skinner 50 22 36 26 31 36
Sasquatch II David W. Skinner 50 16 33 20 20 32
Sasquatch III David W. Skinner 50 14 22 13 12 26
Sasquatch IV David W. Skinner 50 27 37 30 29 36
Sasquatch V David W. Skinner 50 30 36 29 25 38
Sasquatch VI David W. Skinner 50 30 32 25 28 37
Sasquatch VII David W. Skinner 50 30 31 26 26 40
SokEvo Lee J Haywood 107 107 107 107 107 107
SokHard Lee J Haywood 163 163 163 163 137 163
Sven Sven Egevad 1623 1170 1384 1251 1179 1440
XSokoban Thinking Rabbit, ... 90 42 86 84 67 80
Y.M. Auto Yoshio Murase 52 52 52 52 52 52
Y.M. Handmade Yoshio Murase 54 54 54 52 52 54
Total 3272 2553 2880 2680 2559 2952

Download all the test suite levels here or from www.sokobano.de.

Solver Statistics

The statistics shows the results for the leading Sokoban solvers for various level packs. Please note that the grand totals are simple summations. The number of solved unique levels may differ slightly due to duplicate levels in the level packs.

Sokoban Solver Statistics - Solved Levels
Collection Author Levels BoxSearch Takaken YASS JSoko Sokolution
Aymeric Aymeric du Peloux 282 282 282 282 282 282
Grigr2001 Evgeny Grigoriev 100 93 94 93 92 96
Grigr2002 Evgeny Grigoriev 40 37 37 38 36 40
GrigrSpecial Evgeny Grigoriev 40 39 40 40 39 40
Holland David Holland 81 56 65 59 55 66
Microban David W. Skinner 155 155 155 155 155 155
Microban II David W. Skinner 135 134 134 135 135 132
Sasquatch David W. Skinner 50 22 36 26 31 36
Sasquatch II David W. Skinner 50 16 33 20 20 32
Sasquatch III David W. Skinner 50 14 22 13 12 26
Sasquatch IV David W. Skinner 50 27 37 30 29 36
Sasquatch V David W. Skinner 50 30 36 29 25 38
Sasquatch VI David W. Skinner 50 30 32 25 28 37
Sasquatch VII David W. Skinner 50 30 31 26 26 40
Sharpen Sven Egevad 153 34 76 43 48 92
SokEvo Lee J Haywood 107 107 107 107 107 107
SokHard Lee J Haywood 163 163 163 163 137 163
Sokoban Perfect Thinking Rabbit 306 146 261 188 188 236
Sokoban Revenge Thinking Rabbit 306 148 244 194 170 216
Sven Sven Egevad 1911 1416 1652 1520 1426 1721
Y.M. Auto Yoshio Murase 52 52 52 52 52 52
Y.M. Handmade Yoshio Murase 54 54 54 52 52 54
Total 4235 3085 3643 3290 3145 3697

GroupEffort Test Suite

The reason for benchmarking the GroupEffort test suite is to show the limited veracity of the statement made in section "6 Conclusion" of the thesis, where the author writes that the GroupEffort solver "outperforms existing solvers".

The benchmarks show that this was only true for the cherry-picked small test set at the time the thesis was published, never for the presumably more representative large test set.

Sokoban Solver Statistics - GroupEffort Test Suite - Solved Levels
Collection Levels GroupEffort Sokolution Takaken JSoko YASS
Small Set 200 196 (a)(c) 200 (a) 192 (b) 180 (b) 191 (b)
Large Set 2851 1566 (a)(c) 2471 (a) 2462 (b) 2165 (b) 2260 (b)
Total 3051 1762 2671 2654 2345 2471

(a): Time limit: 5 minutes     (b): Time limit: 10 minutes     (c): Best GroupEffort solver configuration

Disclaimer 

Sokoban
=======


Sokoban (R) Registered Trademark of Falcon Co., Ltd., Japan
Sokoban Copyright (C) 1982-2004 by Hiroyuki Imabayashi, Japan
Sokoban Copyright (C) 1989, 1990, 2001-2004 by Falcon Co., Ltd., Japan


License
=======


Redistribution and use of the Sokoban Solver statistics are permitted
provided that the following conditions are met: 


* Redistributions may not be sold, nor may they be used in a commercial product or activity.
* Redistributions must reproduce the entire content of this disclaimer in the documentation
  and/or other materials provided with the distribution.


Credits (in no particular order)
================================


CosmoNotes, CosmoPoly, LOMA, MicroCosmos, MiniCosmos,
NaboCosmos and PicoCosmos level sets
Copyright (C) by Aymeric du Peloux.
E-mail: aymeric.du-peloux@gadz.org
Web site: unknown


dh1, dh2, bagatelle, cantrip, and maelstrom level sets
Copyright (C) by David Holland
E-mail: unknown
Web site: unknown


Microban, Mas Microban, Sasquatch, Mas Sasquatch, Sasquatch III,
Sasquatch IV, Sasquatch V, Sasquatch VI and Sasquatch VII level sets.
Copyright (C) by David W. Skinner
E-mail: sasquatch@bentonrea.com
Web site: unknown


Grigr2001, Grigr2002 and GrigrSpecial level sets
Copyright (C) by Evgeny Grigoriev  (aka GRIGoRusha)
E-mail: grigr@yandex.ru
Web site: http://grigr.narod.ru/


SokEvo and SokHard level sets
Copyright (C) 2002-2006 by Lee J Haywood
E-mail: fruise@gmail.com
Web Site: http://leehaywood.org/games/sokoban/


Sven level set
Copyright (C) 2007 by Sven Egevad
E-mail: sven.egevad@telia.com
Web Site: unknown


Sokoban Perfect and Sokoban Revenge level sets
Copyright (C) 1989, 1991 by Thinking Rabbit
Web Site: https://sokoban.jp/


Y.M. Auto and Y.M. Handmade level sets
Copyright (C) Yoshio Murase 
E-mail: yoshio@asahi.email.ne.jp
Web Site: http://www.ne.jp/asahi/ai/yoshio/sokoban/index.html


BoxSearch
Copyright (C) 2007 by Ge Yong
E-mail: notabdc@hotmail.com
Web site: unknown   


JSoko
Copyright (C) by Matthias Meger
E-mail: JSoko@online.de
Web site: http://www.sokoban-online.de


Sokoban Automatic Solver (aka Takaken solver)
Copyright (C) 2002 - 200X Ken'ichiro Takahashi (aka takaken)
E-mail: takaken@ic-net.or.jp
Web site: http://www.ic-net.or.jp/home/takaken/e/soko/index.html 


YASS - Yet Another Sokoban Solver and Optimizer - For Small Levels
Copyright (C) 2007 by Brian Damgaard
E-mail: BrianDamgaard@jubii.dk
Web site: http://sourceforge.net/projects/sokobanyasc/


Sokoban YASC 
Copyright (C) 2001-2019 by Brian Damgaard
E-mail: BrianDamgaard@jubii.dk
Web Site: https://sourceforge.net/projects/sokobanyasc/


YSokoban
Copyright (C) 2007 by George Petrov
E-mail: YGP@WriteMe.com
Web Site:  http://ygp.orgfree.com/sokoban.html


XSokoban
Copyright (C) by Andrew Myers
E-mail: andru@cs.cornell.edu
Web Site: http://www.cs.cornell.edu/andru/xsokoban.html


Sokofan
Copyright (C) 2005-2007 by Eric Leung
E-mail: eleung2@hotpop.com
Web Site: unknown


Sokolution
Copyright (C) 2016-2019 by Florent DIEDLER
E-mail: fdiedler2000@gmail.com
Web site: http://codeanalysis.fr/sokoban/   


Trademarks
========== 


Company names, brand names and product names are trademarks
or registered trademarks of their respective holders.


Contact
=======


E-mail: sokoban@online.de
Retrieved from "http://sokobano.de/wiki/index.php?title=Solver_Statistics"
Personal tools